Complete classic literature • Five-line readings • Clear US narration
VELMORA ACADEMY
Academy of Archival Languages & Memory Studies
Menu Close
Writing for Vaudeville
Writing for Vaudeville

Chapter XXII

Cover illustration for Writing for Vaudeville
Context Illustration Reading 1/54 · 5 lines
English subtitles · tap any word to listen 1 / 5
THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?
Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:
"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."
This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.
And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.
0:00 / 0:00
Speed 0.75x
AI-generated narration by OpenAI · Slow US English
LEARNER DICTIONARY
Archivist
/ˈɑːrkɪvɪst/
Editorial verification pending

A keeper or guardian of historical records and memories.

Writing for Vaudeville

Chapter XXII

Reading 1/54 · 5 reading units · Lines 1–5

Line 1
THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?
Line 2
Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:
Line 3
"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."
Line 4
This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.
Line 5
And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

Learner Dictionary

Oxford-style entry order: headword, part of speech, US IPA, concise definition, contextual example, audio, and collocations from this reading.

About preposition US /əˈbaʊt/

on the subject of; concerning

From this reading “THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?”

Among preposition US /əˈmʌŋ/

surrounded by; in the middle of a group

From this reading “Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:”

Another noun US /ˈanother/

a story-specific word describing an important person, object, action, or idea in this passage

From this reading “This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.”

Asked noun US /asked/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading “THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?”

Great noun US /great/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading “"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."”

Have auxiliary verb US /hæv/

used with a past participle to form the perfect tenses

From this reading “Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:”

May modal verb US /meɪ/

used to say something is possible, or to give permission

From this reading “"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."”

Must modal verb US /mʌst/

used to say something is necessary, or almost certainly true

From this reading “"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."”

Never noun US /never/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading “THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?”

One pronoun US /wʌn/

used to mean any person in general, including the speaker

From this reading “THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?”

Poor noun US /poor/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading “"A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."”

Question noun US /ˈquestion/

a story-specific word describing an important person, object, action, or idea in this passage

From this reading “THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?”

Yet conjunction US /jet/

but in spite of that

From this reading “And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.”

All words in this reading · 80

Every word is available to listen to. Dictionary details are shown only when verified; these are not licensed Oxford entries.

AdeterminerUS /ə/

used before a singular noun to mean one of a group, when it is not a particular one

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

aboutprepositionUS /əˈbaʊt/

on the subject of; concerning

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

all

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

AmongprepositionUS /əˈmʌŋ/

surrounded by; in the middle of a group

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

andeterminerUS /æn/

the form of “a” used before a word that begins with a vowel sound

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

andconjunctionUS /ənd/

used to join words or parts of a sentence that go together

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

anothernounUS /ˈanother/

a story-specific word describing an important person, object, action, or idea in this passage

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

areauxiliary verbUS /ɑːr/

the form of “be” used with you, we, they, or a plural noun

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

askednounUS /asked/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

authoritative

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

beauxiliary verbUS /biː/

used with a past participle to form the passive, or with -ing for continuous tenses

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

become

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

Bernstein

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

bothdeterminerUS /boʊθ/

the two together, not just one

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

butconjunctionUS /bʌt/

used to introduce something that contrasts with what came before

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

carry

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

chapter

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

Co

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

discussed

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

ELEMENTS

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

fact

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

forprepositionUS /fɔːr/

intended to be given to, or used by, somebody

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

gives

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

greatnounUS /great/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

haveauxiliary verbUS /hæv/

used with a past participle to form the perfect tenses

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

HepronounUS /hiː/

a man, boy, or male animal already mentioned, as the subject

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

IpronounUS /aɪ/

the person speaking or writing, as the subject of the verb

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

important

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

inprepositionUS /ɪn/

inside something, or within a place, period, or state

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

indivisible

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

isauxiliary verbUS /ɪz/

the form of “be” used with he, she, it, or a singular noun

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

known

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

Louis

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

LYRIC

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

maymodal verbUS /meɪ/

used to say something is possible, or to give permission

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

melody

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

more

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

Mr

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

music

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

mustmodal verbUS /mʌst/

used to say something is necessary, or almost certainly true

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

nevernounUS /never/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

noted

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

OFprepositionUS /ʌv/

belonging to, or connected with, somebody or something

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

often

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

OnepronounUS /wʌn/

used to mean any person in general, including the speaker

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

opens

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

orconjunctionUS /ɔːr/

used to join alternatives or possibilities

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

other

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

poornounUS /poor/

an important story-specific word used in this passage

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

popular

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

preceding

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

publishers

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

questionnounUS /ˈquestion/

a story-specific word describing an important person, object, action, or idea in this passage

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

reply

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

said

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

settled

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

Shapiro

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

song

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

song-hit

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

song-writers

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

song-writing

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

stating

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

success

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

SUCCESSFUL

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

summed

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

thatconjunctionUS /ðæt/

used to introduce what somebody said, thought, or felt

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

THEdeterminerUS /ðə/

used before a noun that is already known, already mentioned, or the only one of its kind

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

thisdeterminerUS /ðɪs/

used for a person or thing that is near, or that has just been mentioned

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

toparticleUS /tuː/

used before the base form of a verb to make the infinitive

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

up

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

way

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading This is but another way of stating the fact noted in the preceding chapter, that the words and music of a popular song-hit are indivisible.

whatpronounUS /wʌt/

used to ask for information about something

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

WhichpronounUS /wɪtʃ/

used to introduce a clause giving more about a thing just mentioned

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

whompronounUS /huːm/

the form of “who” used as the object of a verb or preposition

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

widely

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."

willmodal verbUS /wɪl/

used to talk about the future, or about willingness

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

withprepositionUS /wɪð/

in the company of; together with

From this reading Among the publishers with whom I have discussed this question is Louis Bernstein, of Shapiro, Bernstein & Co. He summed up what all the other publishers and song-writers I have known have said:

words

Dictionary entry pending editorial verification. Tap Listen to hear the word.

From this reading THE ELEMENTS OF A SUCCESSFUL LYRIC One question about song-writing is often asked but will never be settled: Which is more important, the music or the words?

yetconjunctionUS /jet/

but in spite of that

From this reading And yet Mr. Bernstein gives an authoritative reply to the question with which this chapter opens.

youpronounUS /juː/

the person or people being spoken to

From this reading "A great melody may carry a poor lyric to success, and a great lyric may carry a poor melody; but for a song to become widely popular you must have both a great melody and a great lyric."